4-Ingredient Quick Pickled Banana Peppers (quick and easy!) (2024)

Super quick, refrigerator Pickled Banana Peppers are a fabulous component to sandwiches, pizza, salads and for general snacking. This banana pepper recipe is for a small batch and is refrigerator ready!

It’s Time for Pickled Banana Peppers!

Peppers are making a showing at the farmers market so just like these Pickled Jalapeños, it’s time to pickle banana peppers too! The Pacific Northwest is a little behind in the pepper department due to our climate. But I always find time to whip up a few batches of pickled peppers in between apple picking and testing fall recipes.

Banana peppers and Hungarian wax peppers are in the same family and they look similar. Their heat can vary depending on which pepper you choose, but Hungarian wax peppers tend to be the hottest out of the two. This banana pepper recipe can be used with either of these peppers.

Quick Guide: How to Make Quick Pickled Banana Peppers

Super simple to pull together, these quick pickled banana peppers are crunchy, slightly spicy, and add so much flavor to your favorite Greek recipes, pizza, sandwiches, and salads. In summary, here’s how to make them (see recipe card for details):

• First, sterilize the jars and lids. The National Center for Home Food Preservation shows us how to sterilize properly.
• Second, thoroughly rinse the peppers to rid them of any dirt or grit.
• Third, chop the peppers into rings.
• Fourth, bring the pickling brine to a boil.
• Fifth, pack the cut peppers into jars. Use a muddler to gently pack the rings, to make room for more.
• Next, pour the boiling brine over the peppers, packing the peppers in and adding more to fill the jar, leaving about a 1/2″ head space.
• Last, lid the peppers and allow them to cool to room temperature.

Store the peppers in the refrigerator until consumed. They’ll be ready for snacking within a few days.

How Hot are Banana Peppers?

Banana peppers are mild with a Scoville range of 0 to 500. In comparison, jalapeño comes in at 2,500–5,000 Scoville units. Hungarian wax peppers have a huge range of 1,500 to 15,000 Scoville units. But I’ve never had one hotter than a jalapeño. I find they’re usually much milder.

What Do Pickled Banana Peppers Taste Like?

Pickled Banana Peppers have a mild heat (sometimes they can be spicy) but are tangy due to the pickling brine. On their own, they’re tangy and slightly sweet. Quick Pickled Banana Peppers stored in the refrigerator will retain their crunch.

Can Pickled Banana Peppers Be Canned?

Yes, but I no longer can my Pickled Banana Peppers because canning softens the peppers. I prefer crunchy pepper rings. However, USDA recommends canning them.

Equipment for Pickling

To make pickling easier, I use a few pieces of special equipment. (These are affiliate links).

• Wide Mouth Funnel
• Canning Jars – I like 16oz Mason jars for these peppers
• Four Cup Measuring Glass

Recipe Tips

• This recipe is for refrigerator quick Pickled Banana Peppers. For canning instructions, see USDA recommendations.
• I’ve been making this recipe for years and have found that canning softens the peppers, so I choose to skip canning and refrigerate the peppers after pickling. This way, the peppers retain their crunch.
• Look for firm green, sometimes red banana peppers or Hungarian wax peppers to use in this recipe. Hungarian wax tend have the most heat out of the two.
• Wearing disposable gloves will help protect hands from the oils that make the peppers hot! The capsaicin can have a lingering burn. Otherwise, wash your hands with hot soapy water after handling the peppers.
• I’ve stored quick Pickled Banana Peppers in the refrigerator for up to three months. They tend to get eaten quickly, so I’m not sure how much longer they’ll keep.

Recipes to Use Quick Pickled Banana Peppers On

• 5 Ingredient Sourdough Pizza Crust
• Italian Pressed Sandwich
• Greek Pizza
• Black Bean Walnut Burgers
• Smashed Pimento Chickpea Sandwich
• Gluten Free Pizza
• Greek Pita Sandwiches

• Fall
• Summer